Deep Plane Facelift versus SMAS Facelift
When patients ask me about the differences between a SMAS facelift and an extended deep plane facelift, what they’re really asking is: Which one delivers better results? The truth is, these are fundamentally different operations with different goals, techniques, and outcomes. While the SMAS facelift may still be appropriate in select cases, the extended deep plane facelift has become the gold standard for comprehensive, natural, and long-lasting facial rejuvenation. Below, I’ll explain why.
What Is the Extended Deep Plane Facelift and Why Is It the Gold Standard?
The extended deep plane facelift is widely regarded as the most advanced and effective facelift technique available today. Unlike traditional approaches that manipulate surface-level tissue or pull the skin tight, the deep plane technique involves lifting and repositioning the deeper layers of the face—including the SMAS, deep fat pads, and retaining ligaments.
What sets it apart is the extent of the dissection. By fully releasing the retaining ligaments and mobilizing the facial soft tissue in the deep plane, we’re able to lift the face vertically and naturally. This vertical vector more closely mimics youthful anatomy and avoids the tight, windblown look seen with older facelift styles.
It may sound counterintuitive, but the more extensive dissection in an extended deep plane facelift actually yields results that are more natural—not less. That’s the paradox: the procedure that goes deeper and further ends up looking softer and more organic. When done correctly, this technique rejuvenates the cheeks, jawline, and neck in a way no other method can match.
Not All “Deep Plane Facelifts” Are Created Equal
In today’s aesthetic market, the term “deep plane facelift” gets thrown around far too casually. The truth is, any surgeon can label their procedure as a deep plane facelift—regardless of whether it truly involves the deep dissection, release of retaining ligaments, and precise mobilization of facial structures that define the technique. Just because it’s called a deep plane doesn’t mean it is one.
Surgical expertise varies widely. While the deep plane approach is technically more demanding, its success is ultimately dependent on the surgeon’s experience, anatomical knowledge, and innate surgical ability. That’s why reviewing actual facelift results—not just credentials or procedure names—is critical.
It’s also worth noting that a highly skilled surgeon performing a SMAS lift may still achieve better, more natural-looking results than a less experienced surgeon performing what they market as a “deep plane” facelift. Technique matters, but so does execution.
This is why choosing a surgeon based on demonstrated outcomes is essential. If you’re considering a deep plane facelift, be sure you’re seeing consistent, natural, and transformative results—not just hearing buzzwords.
Contact Dr. Brian Harmych
*Filling out this form will not place you on our email list.
What Is a SMAS Facelift?
The SMAS facelift—short for Superficial Musculoaponeurotic System facelift—is one of the most commonly performed facial rejuvenation procedures. The SMAS is a fibrous tissue layer that lies beneath the skin and above the deeper facial muscles and fat pads. In this technique, the SMAS layer is lifted, repositioned, and secured to improve sagging in the lower face and jawline.
SMAS facelifts are often considered an upgrade from “skin-only” facelifts because they target structural support rather than simply tightening the surface. For the right patient—typically someone with mild to moderate facial aging—the SMAS facelift can offer a noticeable improvement in jawline definition and jowl correction.
However, there are limitations. The SMAS layer is typically lifted and tightened without fully releasing the underlying retaining ligaments or performing deep dissection. As a result, the lift is often more lateral or diagonal in direction, which can sometimes look tight or unnatural—especially in patients with midface volume descent or heavier necks.
This is one of the main reasons I favor the extended deep plane facelift for most patients. The deep plane approach goes beneath the SMAS layer, allowing for complete mobilization of the deeper structures—including the facial retaining ligaments and deep fat pads. This results in a more comprehensive, vertical lift that restores youthful contouring across the cheeks, jawline, and neck—all without looking pulled.
Another important consideration is long-term outcome—particularly for patients considering a second or third facelift. SMAS facelifts tend to look progressively less natural with each subsequent procedure. That’s because the vector of lift becomes less favorable as skin and soft tissue are repeatedly redraped in unnatural directions. Over time, this can result in an awkward, windswept appearance that’s difficult to correct and almost impossible to camouflage.
While the SMAS facelift may still have a role in carefully selected cases, especially in younger patients or those seeking more limited correction, it simply does not offer the same degree of rejuvenation, natural movement, or longevity that we consistently achieve with the deep plane technique.
| Feature | Extended Deep Plane Facelift | SMAS Facelift |
|---|---|---|
| Surgical Technique | Lifts and repositions deep muscle, fascia, and fat pads beneath the SMAS layer | Tightens and repositions superficial muscular layer (SMAS) only |
| Natural Appearance | More natural, youthful, and soft due to complete mobilization and ligament release | May appear tighter or stretched, especially with repeat procedures |
| Longevity of Results | Typically 10–15 years | Typically 5–10 years |
| Ideal Candidates | Patients seeking comprehensive facial rejuvenation with lasting, natural results | Patients looking for moderate facial rejuvenation with shorter surgical time |
| Revision Risk | Lower risk due to more complete lift and repositioning | Higher, especially in younger patients or after mini facelifts |
| Cost | Higher due to technical complexity and surgeon skill | Lower upfront cost, but may require earlier revision |
Why “More Surgery” Can Look More Natural
There’s a common misconception that more invasive surgery always looks more obvious — but when it comes to facial rejuvenation, the opposite is often true. The extended deep plane facelift is a perfect example of this paradox. Because it involves deeper release and more comprehensive dissection, it allows the face to move and settle in a way that looks soft, smooth, and completely natural.
Rather than relying on skin tension to create the lift — which often leads to an unnatural, pulled appearance — the deep plane technique repositions the structural layers of the face: the ligaments, fascia, muscles, and deep fat pads. This true structural lift allows the skin to redrape without tension, resulting in an organic, vertical elevation that restores youthful contours without signaling to the world that anything was done.
In short, more surgical precision doesn’t mean a more “done” look — it means better anatomy, better movement, and better results.
How Dr. Harmych Approaches Facelifting
Dr. Harmych is one of only a few facial plastic surgeons in Ohio performing true extended deep plane facelifts — and one of even fewer doing so with such a meticulous and customized approach. His background in facial anatomy and his advanced fellowship training allow him to perform this complex procedure with extraordinary precision and control.
Dr. Harmych carefully evaluates each patient’s facial structure, skin quality, soft tissue volume, and aging pattern before recommending any surgical plan. His approach is never one-size-fits-all — it’s based on thoughtful patient selection, customized surgical design, and a deep understanding of how to achieve the most natural, long-lasting rejuvenation.
For patients who are truly ready for comprehensive facial restoration, Dr. Harmych’s extended deep plane facelift offers the most sophisticated and effective option available.
| Frequently Asked Questions | Answers |
|---|---|
| What is a deep plane facelift? | A deep plane facelift lifts and repositions the deeper facial structures—muscles, ligaments, and fat pads—beneath the SMAS layer. This technique provides more natural, longer-lasting rejuvenation of the midface, jawline, and neck without the tight or pulled appearance of older facelift methods. |
| How is it different from a traditional facelift? | Traditional facelifts typically lift only the skin or superficial tissue. A deep plane facelift releases retaining ligaments and repositions deeper facial structures, creating a more natural contour and longer-lasting result—especially in the midface and lower face. |
| Who is a good candidate? | Healthy adults with moderate to advanced facial aging, including sagging cheeks, jowls, or neck skin. Dr. Harmych evaluates each patient individually to determine if an extended deep plane facelift is appropriate for their goals. |
| How long do the results last? | Results typically last 10–15 years. Because the deeper support structures are repositioned—not just the skin—the improvement is more durable and ages more naturally than traditional techniques. |
| What’s the recovery like? | Most patients return to light activity within 10–14 days. Expect about 3 weeks of social downtime. Swelling and bruising improve over several weeks, and results continue to refine over 3–6 months. |
| Is it safe? | Yes. When performed by a trained facial plastic surgeon like Dr. Harmych, the deep plane facelift is a safe, advanced procedure with high patient satisfaction and low complication rates. |
| Why don’t all surgeons offer this technique? | The deep plane facelift requires extensive anatomical knowledge and refined surgical skill. Not all surgeons are trained in this technique, and not all who advertise it perform a true deep plane procedure. That’s why results—and the surgeon’s experience—matter most. |
Contact Dr. Brian Harmych
*Filling out this form will not place you on our email list.
Additional information on SMAS vs Deep Plane Facelift
https://www.harmychplasticsurgery.com/deep-plane-facelift-cleveland-ohio/
